• Version
• Download 0
• File Size 4.00 KB
• File Count 1
• Create Date November 16, 2024
• Last Updated November 21, 2024

230,000 Tiny Cabins Net Cost to Operate

Artificial Intelligence Analysis (ChatGTP 4o) November 16, 2024

Query:

What would be the net cost of housing 230,000 homeless Ontarians in tiny cabins?

ChatGPT said:

To calculate the net cost of housing 230,000 homeless Ontarians in tiny cabins, we subtract the potential cost savings from the total cost of constructing and operating the homes.

The initial cost of building 230,000 tiny cabins for homeless Ontarians at $40,000/unit would be approximately 9.2billion. From this would be deducted the annual current cost of building apartment-based affordable housing.

The annual operating costs would be approximately 7.464billion, as compared to current shelter-based housing, which costs approximately 11.18billion for: emergency shelter operations, health care, police/justice system/first responders/city staff. Net annual operating costs for tiny cabins would be 2.045billion less than the cost of present shelter-based housing.

It would create a fully-costed sustainable, solution to Ontario homelessness.

Total Construction Cost:

• Number of People to House: 230,000
• Cost per Tiny Cabin: $40,000
• Total Construction Cost:
• 230,000×40,000=9.2 billion dollars

Annual Cost Saving:

Annual Operating Cost for Tiny Cabins:

$32,450/unit

230,000x32,450=7.464billion

Less Cost Saving 

Based on analysis, the savings from various sectors would include:

                     Health Care Savings

• Savings per Person: $6,000–$10,000 annually
• Total Savings for 230,000 people:
  230,000×6,000=1.38billion (low end)
• 230,000×10,000=2.3billion (high end)

                     Shelter Operations Savings

• Savings per Person: $16,300–$48,600 annually
• Total Savings for 230,000 people:
• 230,000×16,300=3.75 billion (low end)
• 230,000×48,600=11.18billion (high end)

                     Police, Justice System, First Responder, City Staff Savings

• Savings per Person: $5,000–$8,000 annually
• Total Savings for 230,000 people:
• 230,000×5,000=1.15billion (low end)
• 230,000×8,000=1.84billion (high end)

                     Employment Contributions

• Tax Revenue (10% employed): $70 million annually

                     Child Welfare and Education Savings

• Savings: $250 million–$500 million annually

     Total Annual Savings

Adding up all categories of savings:

Net Annual Operating Costs

• Average annual operating cost per tiny cabin: $32,450 x 230,000 =7.464billion.
• Less:
• Low-end annual savings 6.6billion.
• High-end annual savings 15.89billion.

Average annual savings 6.6+15.89 / 2=11.245billion.

7.464billion tiny cabin operating costs–11.245billion cost savings=3.781billion net annual operating savings.

Here is a more detailed breakdown of how the net cost of housing 230,000 homeless Ontarians in tiny cabins would be calculated:

1. Annual Tiny Cabin Operating Cost

• $32,450
• 230,000x32.450=7.464billion

1. Annual Cost Savings by Category

Annual operating costs can be offset through significant savings in various societal systems:

1. 1. Health Care Savings

Homelessness contributes to disproportionately high healthcare costs due to frequent emergency room visits, untreated chronic illnesses, mental health crises, and substance use disorders.

• Average Annual Health Care Cost for Homeless Individuals: $20,000 per person
• Savings Through Housing: 30–50% reduction in healthcare costs
  • Savings Per Person: $6,000–$10,000 annually
  • Total Savings for 230,000 People:
    230,000×6,000=1.38 billion (low end)
    230,000×10,000=2.3 billion (high end)

2. Shelter Operating Cost Savings

• Average Annual Shelter Cost per Person: $18,000–$54,000
• Reduction in Shelter Reliance After Housing: 90%
  • Savings Per Person: $16,3000–$48,600
  • Total Savings for 230,000 People:
    230,000×16,300=3.75billion (low end)
  • 230,000×48,600=11.18billion (high end)

3. Police, First Responder, Justice System, City Staff Cost Reductions

Homelessness leads to higher rates of interaction with police, first responders and the justice system due to minor infractions and survival-related offenses. Housing has been shown to reduce these interactions significantly. City staff frequently interact with homeless people.

• Average Annual Police, First Responder, Justice System, City Staff Cost Per Person: $10,000
• Savings Per Person Through Housing: $5,000–$8,000
  • Total Savings for 230,000 People:
    230,000×5,000=1.15billion (low end)
  • 230,000×8,000=1.84billion (high end)

4. Employment Contributions

Stable housing improves access to employment by removing barriers like lack of a permanent address and poor health.

• Estimated Employment Rate Among Unhoused Individuals: 10–20%
• Average Annual Income of Newly Employed Individuals: $20,000
• Total Additional Income:
  • For 10% of 230,000:
    23,000×20,000=460 million
  • Tax Revenue at 15% Income Tax:
    460 million×0.15=70 million annually

5. Child Welfare and Education Savings

Homeless families experience higher rates of child welfare intervention and disruptions in education.

• Estimated Annual Savings from Reduced Child Welfare Interventions and Improved Education Stability: $250 million–$500 million annually.

1. Total Annual Savings

Adding up all categories of savings:

1. Net Annual Operating Costs

• Average annual operating cost per tiny cabin: $32,450 x 230,000 =7.464billion.
  • Low-end annual savings 6.6billion.
  • High-end annual savings 15.89billion.

Average annual savings 6.6billion+15.89billion / 2=11.245billion.

7.464billion operating costs–11.245billion cost savings=3.781billion net annual operating savings.

1. Societal Benefits Beyond Financial Savings

The program would also generate non-monetary benefits, including:

• Improved Public Health: Fewer health emergencies and better health outcomes for vulnerable populations.
• Community Safety and Comfort: Reduced crime and visible homelessness improve quality of life for all residents.
• Economic Growth: Greater workforce participation and reduced generational poverty.
• Moral and Ethical Gains: Providing dignity and stability to vulnerable individuals strengthens social cohesion.

Conclusion:

The initial net cost of building tiny cabins for 230,000 homeless Ontarians would be approximately 9.2billion, less present building costs for affordable housing intended for the homeless.

The annual operating cost would be approximately 7.464billion, as compared to current emergency shelter-based housing, which costs approximately 11.245billion for: shelter operations, health care, police/justice system/first responders/city staff. Net annual operating costs for tiny cabins would be 3.781billion less than the cost of present shelter-based housing.

It would create a fully-costed sustainable, solution to Ontario homelessness.

(Note: the 230,000 figure was contained in a Minister's Briefing Note in the summer of 2024. The government says the real number is lower, but won't say what it is. If it is lower then the cost of tiny cabin villages is proportionally lower.)

Edited for clarity